Roman Catholic Head Coach Rick Prete made the aggressive move to go for it instead of punting and most likely trail at the half. The Cahillites converted and scored a touchdown on that same drive, turning the tide of the PIAA 5A State Semifinal against West Chester Rustin. The touchdown started an avalanche of scoring that lifted Roman Catholic to a 41-17 win on Friday Night at West Chester Henderson’s J. Oscar Dicks Stadium and its first appearance in a PIAA State Final in program history.
“Win the game,” Prete said. “You have to take those opportunities and that was not a spot to be conservative. You have to go take it when you have I think the best player in the State in Eyan Stead with the ball in his hands in that situation. We trust our defense as well in that spot.”
The Cahillites (11-4) saw two of its first four drives of the game end in fumbles with the first ending a promising drive that made it to the Rustin 39-yard line. The second fumble set the Golden Knights (13-2) up at the Roman Catholic 29-yard line to conclude the first quarter. Freddie Adler gave Rustin the initial 3-0 lead with a 30-yard field goal following the fumble.
The stage was set for Prete’s aggressive 4th-and-1 call after the teams traded punts. His defense had limited the Golden Knights to just two first downs at that point and trailed by just three despite the two turnovers. Eyan Stead bounced around the left side and picked up 16 critical yards to convert the fourth down for the Cahillites. Stead finished the drive with an 18-yard touchdown reception that gave Roman Catholic the 7-3 lead at halftime.
“We had trouble keeping up when they went to their fast tempo,” Rustin head coach Mike St. Clair said. “There were a couple of breakdowns on that last drive in the first half and then we got worn down in the second half. The way we tried to win was establishing long time-consuming drives but they shut us down.”
Roman Catholic needed less than two minutes to extend its lead to 14-3 to open the second half as Stead snagged a 29-yard touchdown pass from Beals for his second score of the game. With the Golden Knights now on their heels, Eisa Nealy took a screen pass 46 yards for a touchdown on the next Cahillites drive that made it 21-3.
“I tip my hat for what Rustin was able to do early on defense,” Prete said. “We were able to flip it by not pressing and trying to force ourselves to make a big play on every play. With the style they play, it was imperative to score before the half and get the ball to start the third quarter. It allowed us to set the tempo.”
The Golden Knights turned to its do-it-all running back Chase Hatton to give them hope with the game slipping away and he returned the ensuing kickoff 45 yards to set up the drive at the Roman Catholic 30-yard line. JoJo Magolon caught a 24-yard pass on 3rd-and-11 and Hatton scored from seven yards out on the next play that cut the deficit to 21-10 with 3:33 left in the third quarter.
However, any hope was quickly vanquished by Cahillites running back, JoJo Delecce who started the 4th Quarter with a 44-yard touchdown run that made it 28-10. Rustin fumbled on its first play of the next drive and Beals tossed his fourth and final touchdown pass of the night to Nealy that made it 34-10.
“I always want to make sure my wide receivers eat,” Beals said. “I am super honored to help lead this team to its first state final.”
Beals, the city all-time passing leader, threw for 309 yards on 24-of-36 passing with his four touchdown strikes. Nealy and Stead had similar totals of five catches each for 98 and 94 yards along, respectively. Tayden Mines led all receivers with 10 catches for 102 yards.
The Cahillites closed out the win by letting the combo of Delecce and Jeremiah Tabb pound its way through a very strong Rustin defense. Tabb capped off the night with a 17-yard touchdown late in the fourth quarter.
“Our offensive line was phenomenal, and our running backs bounced back from ball security problems,” Prete said. “That allowed us to get settled in by establishing the run and Semaj was able to spread them out.”
Roman Catholic held a decisive 541-172 total offense advantage behind a balanced attack of 309 passing yards and 232 rushing yards.
Hatton, the all-time Rustin leader in offensive touchdowns, finished his career by just hitting the century mark with 100 yards on 14 carries and scored a second touchdown from a 60-yard run late in the fourth quarter. Behind a 30-man senior class, the Golden Knights captured their second District 1 Championship in program history.
“I am really proud of this team,” St. Clair said. “13 wins, beat a lot of top teams in this area, and a District Championship. Just hats off to these kids and this senior class will go down as a special one for this program.”
The Cahillites get their chance at a State Championship that had eluded them before, especially the last two years where they saw their season end at the hands of Imhotep Charter in agonizing fashion both times. They will take on a former State Champion in Bishop McDevitt that much like the Cahillites, are no short of on-field talent.
“We still have more work to do, and we have another game to get ready for.” Prete said. “This chance to play for a State Title next week is a culmination of all the work of these guys. This is not a one year thing this is our sixth year at this, and we have been chipping away. We have learned from our setbacks to Imhotep to work hard and we have a heck of an opportunity in front of us against a heck of an opponent next week.”
SCORE BY QUARTERS | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Final |
Roman Catholic | 0 | 7 | 14 | 20 | 41 |
WC Rustin | 0 | 3 | 7 | 7 | 17 |
Scoring summary
2 | WCR | Adler, 30 FG | 9:16 |
2 | RC | Stead, 18 pass from Beals (Pollack kick) | 1:08 |
3 | RC | Stead, 29 pass from Beals (Pollack kick) | 10:40 |
3 | RC | Nealy, 46 pass from Beals (Pollack kick) | 5:40 |
3 | WCR | Hatton, 7 run (Adler kick) | 3:33 |
4 | RC | Delecce, 44 run (Pollack kick) | 11:52 |
4 | RC | Nealy, 4 pass from Beals (Kick Blocked) | 10:03 |
4 | RC | Tabb, 17 run (Pollack kick) | 5:44 |
4 | WCR | Hatton, 60 run (Adler kick) | 5:23 |
Team statistics
Roman Catholic | WC Rustin | |
First downs | 24 | 7 |
Rushes-yards | 30-232 | 36-132 |
Passing yards | 309 | 40 |
Total yards | 541 | 172 |
Passes COMP-ATT-INT | 24-36-0 | 6-10-0 |
Fumbles-lost | 3-2 | 2-2 |
Punts-average | 2-32.0 | 6-34.0 |
Penalties-yards | 10-74 | 6-42 |
Individual statistics
RUSHING
Roman Catholic: Delecce 15-117, Tabb 10-66, Stead 2-19, Beals 2-16, Scott 1-14
WC Rustin: Hatton 14-100, Loper 9-29, Magolon 3-10, Dav. Jacobs 4-10, McClain 4-(-4), TEAM 2-(-13)
PASSING
Roman Catholic: Beals 24-36-0—309
WC Rustin: McClain 6-10-0–40
RECEIVING
Roman Catholic: Mines 10-102, Nealy 5-98, Stead 5-94, Scott 3-9, Newuan 1-6
WC Rustin: Magolon 3-34, Hatton 3-6