* Selections based on the entire season. Not just league play!
| COACH OF THE YEAR: | Tim Roken | SJ Prep | |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR: | Samaj Jones (Jr.) QB | SJ Prep | |
| OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: | Samaj Jones (Jr.) QB | SJ Prep | |
| DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: | Cole Nilles LB | SJ Prep | |
| 1st Team Offense: | Honorable Mentions: | ||
| Offensive Line: | Archbishop Wood: | ||
| Cole Evans – Wood | Luke Shaeffer – DB | ||
| Lakeem Steele (Jr.) – SJ Prep | Eric Gardner – DL | ||
| George Reinhard – SJ Prep | Brian Nangle – LB | ||
| Austin Ramsey – Roman | Kevin Heywood (Jr.) – OL | ||
| Julian Cervantes – SJ Prep | Ryan Wilson – RB | ||
| Sean Broderick (Jr.) – Judge | |||
| Father Judge: | |||
| Quarterback: | Brayden McLaughlin – LB | ||
| Samaj Jones (Jr.) – SJ Prep | Tearran Peete – LB | ||
| Andrew Wegner – DL | |||
| Running Back: | Thomas Gonglik (Jr.) – OL | ||
| Khaseem Phillips (Jr.) – SJ Prep | Tyler Yerkov (Jr.) – QB | ||
| Jamir Robertson – Roman | Christopher Coulter (Jr.) – OL | ||
| Denzel Dunbar (Jr.) – DE | |||
| Wide Receiver: | |||
| Tyseer Denmark (Jr.) – Roman | LaSalle: | ||
| David Washington (Jr.) – SJ Prep | Carson Wakefield (Jr.) – DB | ||
| Nole Henry – LaSalle | Matt Wills (Jr.) – LB | ||
| Mekhi Johnson – DB | |||
| Tight End: | James Dolan (Soph.) – MP | ||
| Markus Dixon – Wood | Stevie Davis (Jr.) – RB | ||
| Nick Remish (Soph.) – P | |||
| Multi-Purpose: | Lukas Donahue (Jr.) – OL | ||
| Brandon Rehmann (Jr.) – SJ Prep | |||
| Nymeir Appling (Jr.) – Judge | Roman: | ||
| Brandon Mack – LB | |||
| Kicker: | Samir Thompson-Dean (Jr.) – DL | ||
| Skyler Sholder (Jr.) – SJ Prep | Dazhaun Hopkins (Jr.) – DB | ||
| Richard Mosely – DB | |||
| Punter: | Mao Howell – RB | ||
| Dane Pizaro (Jr.) – Judge | Semaj Beals (Frosh.) – QB | ||
| Aiden Willis (Jr.) – OL | |||
| 1st-Team Defense: | Kahlil Stewart (Soph.) – OL | ||
| Mikey Preston (Jr.) – DB | |||
| Defensive Line: | |||
| Darold Dengohe – LaSalle | SJ Prep: | ||
| Matt DuMond – SJ Prep | Andrew Bachmann – DB | ||
| Rakeem Reffile – Roman | Maxwell Roy (Soph.) – DL | ||
| Kevin Towns (Jr.) – OL | |||
| OLB/Defensive End: | Joseph McMahon – OL | ||
| Jamiel Lyons – Roman | Ivan Bailey-Green (Jr.) – DL | ||
| Jason Patterson – Roman | Elijah Jones (Jr.) – WR | ||
| Sean McNulty (Jr.) – SJ Prep | Nick McGlynn (Jr.) – OLB | ||
| Sean McFadden – LaSalle | |||
| Linebacker: | |||
| Cole Nilles – SJ Prep | |||
| Josiah Trotter – SJ Prep | |||
| Jordan Montgomery – Roman | |||
| Michael Fileppo – LaSalle | |||
| Defensive Back: | |||
| Anthony Sacca (Soph.) – SJ Prep | |||
| Jake Marquis – Judge | |||
| Jah Jah Boyd (Jr.) – Roman | |||
| Omillio Agard (Jr.) – SJ Prep | |||
| Kelby Hampton (Jr.) – LaSalle |
